It's September 2010. After nearly a year of work in a much more open process than had been undertaken prior to September 2009, the City has a new, lower fee contract for waste collection.
A year ago, the City was going to award the contract to Earth First. Now, the contract is being awarded to Republic Service's National Serv-All. It is clear that the willingness of Earth First to engage in the process resulted in a lower bid from Serv-All than Serv-All's current contract.
You might remember that the City of Fort Wayne trash contract was the subject of much controversy one year ago. The Henry administration had prepared an ordinance in 2009 to award the trash contract to Earth First LLC. Earth First was going to use a transfer station owned by Summit City Recycling and Transfer LLC on Pontiac Street east of Anthony Boulevard.
The ordinance approving the award of the contract by the administration's Board of Works was to have been introduced September 22, 2009. It became the subject of a controversy regarding the ownership interests of the transfer station on Pontiac Street east of Anthony Boulevard.
The City Administration began its presentation last night by remarking the Mayor had been committed to making the process of selecting a contractor for the city's waste hauling as open and inclusive as possible.
However, that open process only began after the storm of controversy over the adminstration's first attempt to award the contract in 2009
In the midst of this, I questioned the presenters last night if they were aware of discussion in the community that Summit City Recycling and Transfer was being sold? They indicated they were and some discussion ensued.
The rumored buyer? Republic - the parent of the new awardee of the city trash hauling contract.
That part of the discussion at last night's Council meeting was not mentioned in print coverage of the waste contract vote.
If you need a litte refreshing of the 2009 controversy here is an excerpt from the JG story by Ben Lanka from September 23, 2009:
A contract with a startup company linked to Mayor Tom Henry’s brother was pulled from the City Council’s agenda Tuesday to give the administration more time to vet the firm.
[ ... ]
Vince Robinson, public information director for the mayor, said the bill was withheld so the administration could further investigate the financial standing of the company, which was founded in July. He said some concerns were raised internally and by council members about the contract, but he said this does not mean the city is reconsidering other companies.
[ ... ]
The firm will occupy the former Fort Wayne Foundry site on Pontiac Street next to the solid waste transfer station owned by Summit Recycling & Transfer LLC. To get space for offices, a shop and truck parking, Earth First gave a 5 percent ownership stake to Jerry Henry, a principal in the transfer station and the mayor’s brother.
[ ... ]
Robinson said Jerry Henry’s connection to the bid had no influence on the company’s being selected. Jerry Henry said Tuesday he understands the concerns. City officials should take their time making a decision, he said.
Councilwoman Liz Brown, R-at large, said she is concerned about how the award to Earth First would look to residents, although she doesn’t believe anything inappropriate transpired.
“Nobody’s going to believe that this was just serendipity,” she said.
Councilwoman Karen Goldner, D-2nd, said Jerry Henry’s involvement does not mean it’s a bad deal. She said it’s appropriate the city is making sure a new company can handle such an important service for residents.
Recent Comments